Audio file
Contributors
Creator: Wells, Andrew
Date Recorded
1977-03-17
Date Digitized
2024
Genre
Rights
All content on this site is made available for personal research and private study only. Any other reuse, reproduction, or re-purposing may require the permission of the rightsholder(s); please contact the UPEI Library for more information on permissions/clearances.
Physical Location
Original cassette held by UPEI Archives and Special Collections
Duration
01:56:35
Model
1 1 Item in Collection
Transcript
00:00 Introduction

06:30 Wells begins speaking

09:30 Discussion of arguments pertaining to the use of pesticides and herbicides

12:00 Discussion of arguments for the use of pesticides and herbicides

13:00 Discussion of the sales of pesticides

14:00 Discussion of the perception that it is the misuse of pesticides that causes environmental issues

16:00 Discussion of the use of pesticides with their effects being unknown

17:00 Houston begins speaking

18:30 Discussion of the benefits of fertilisers, pesticides

19:30 Discussion of the history of pesticides

20:30 Discussion of insects affected by pesticides

22:00 Discussion of the importance of biological controls, need to supplement

22:30 Discussion of aphids and potatoes

24:00 Discussion of negative impacts of not using pesticides and herbicides

25:00 Discussion of potato blight

26:30 Discussion of conventionally produced food; fossil fuels

27:30 Discussion of the study of pesticide use

28:00 Manley begins speaking

30:00 Discussion of the agricultural revolution

30:30 Discussion of the infeasibility of banning pesticides outright

32:30 Discussion of genetically modified crops dependent on fertilisers

33:30 Discussion of gas analysis

35:30 Discussion of forestry

38:00 Discussion of the biological implications of pesticide use

38:30 White begins speaking

39:30 Discussion of White's experiences with farming

42:00 Discussion of the Department of Agriculture's recommendations for pesticide use

43:00 Further discussion of White's experiences with farming and pesticide use

44:30 Discussion of crop and economic effects of pesticide use

46:30 Discussion of biological controls for insects

47:00 Discussion of soil replenishment

48:30 Discussion of fertilisers

49:30 End of presentations, beginning of rebuttal period

50:00 Rebuttal from Wells

57:00 Rebuttal from Houston

59:30 Rebuttal from Manley

01:05:00 Rebuttal from White

01:07:00 Recess in seminar

01:07:30 Beginning of question period

01:08:00 Question regarding nuanced uses of pesticides

01:13:00 Question regarding the use of traditional farming

01:22:00 Question regarding microbial activity in soil in relation to fertilisers

01:29:00 Question regarding empirical data on the use of pesticides

01:33:30 Question regarding education related to agricultural practices

01:34:30 Question regarding the impact of economic pressure on agricultural practices

01:37:00 Question regarding agricultural practices in developing countries

01:40:00 Question regarding the role of pesticide producing companies

01:42:30 Question regarding the standard of living in developing countries

01:46:00 Question regarding MPK and trace elements in soil

01:47:30 Discussion of trace element deficiencies in PEI's soil

01:49:30 Discussion of a vote on the outcome of the debate; further discussion of pesticides

01:53:00 Audience vote on the outcome of the debate

01:54:00 Question regarding government support for farming

01:56:00 End of seminar